The Genesis of Value Averaging

Value averaging emerged as a concept in the 1980s, introduced by former Harvard University endowment manager Michael E. Edleson. It was designed as an enhancement to the widely popular dollar-cost averaging method, which involves investing a fixed amount at regular intervals regardless of market conditions.

The key distinction lies in its dynamic approach to investment sizing. Unlike its predecessor, value averaging adjusts the amount invested based on the portfolio’s performance relative to a predetermined growth path. This means investing more when prices are low and less (or even selling) when prices are high, theoretically amplifying returns over time.

Mechanics of Value Averaging

At its core, value averaging requires investors to set a target growth rate for their portfolio and make regular adjustments to stay on this trajectory. Here’s how it typically works:

1. Define a target growth rate (e.g., 0.5% per month).

2. Calculate the target portfolio value for each investment period.

3. Adjust investments to bring the actual portfolio value in line with the target.

For instance, if the target value is $10,500 after six months, but the portfolio is only worth $10,000, the investor would need to add $500. Conversely, if the portfolio exceeds the target, the investor might reduce their contribution or potentially sell some assets.

Potential Benefits of Value Averaging

Value averaging’s proponents argue that it offers several advantages over traditional investment strategies:

1. Automated buy-low, sell-high behavior: By design, the strategy encourages larger investments when prices are depressed and smaller ones (or sales) when prices are elevated.

2. Emotional detachment: The systematic nature of value averaging can help investors avoid making impulsive decisions based on market sentiment.

3. Potentially higher returns: Some studies suggest that value averaging may outperform dollar-cost averaging over long periods, especially in volatile markets.

4. Disciplined saving: The strategy enforces a regular saving habit, adapting to both personal financial changes and market fluctuations.

Challenges and Considerations

While value averaging presents an intriguing approach to long-term investing, it’s not without its challenges:

1. Complexity: Implementing value averaging requires more calculations and active management compared to simpler strategies.

2. Cash flow unpredictability: The varying investment amounts can make budgeting more difficult, potentially requiring a significant cash reserve.

3. Tax implications: More frequent buying and selling can lead to increased tax events, particularly in taxable accounts.

4. Market timing concerns: Critics argue that the strategy may inadvertently encourage a form of market timing, which has been shown to be difficult to execute successfully over long periods.

Real-World Application and Performance

To truly understand the potential of value averaging, it’s crucial to examine its performance in various market conditions. Historical backtests have shown mixed results, with value averaging often outperforming in volatile markets but potentially lagging in steadily rising markets.

A study published in the Journal of Financial Planning found that value averaging produced higher internal rates of return compared to dollar-cost averaging in most scenarios tested. However, the strategy’s outperformance was not consistent across all market conditions and time periods.

Practical implementation of value averaging has seen increased interest among DIY investors and some robo-advisors. These platforms leverage technology to automate the complex calculations required, making the strategy more accessible to a broader range of investors.

---

Essential Value Averaging Insights

• Start with a small portion of your portfolio to test the strategy’s fit for your investment style.

• Maintain a significant cash reserve to accommodate varying investment amounts.

• Consider using value averaging in tax-advantaged accounts to minimize tax implications.

• Regularly review and adjust your target growth rate to ensure it aligns with realistic market expectations.

• Combine value averaging with broad market index funds or ETFs to minimize individual stock risk.

---

As the investment landscape continues to evolve, strategies like value averaging offer intriguing alternatives to traditional approaches. While it’s not a one-size-fits-all solution, value averaging presents a thoughtful method for investors looking to capitalize on market volatility and maintain disciplined investment habits.

Ultimately, the decision to implement value averaging should be based on individual financial goals, risk tolerance, and the ability to manage a more complex investment strategy. As with any investment approach, thorough research and possibly consultation with a financial advisor are crucial steps before incorporating value averaging into your financial plan.